March 27, 2019
“Frustrated” boyfriend shook baby so hard her eyes bled
Carl James said the baby “never took to him”
A man shook his girlfriend’s baby daughter so hard she suffered potentially life-threatening brain injuries.
The defenceless 13-month-old suffered bleeding on the brain and the back of her eyes as well as bruising to both ears, head and to her back at the hands of Carl James.
Jurors found that James, 41, from Wirral, who said the child had never taken to him, had caused the injuries in just half an hour while her mum Kelly Parry went to a counselling session.
The now toddler has made a good recovery but was in foster care for nine months away from both her parents while investigations were made into who had injured her.
“Some issue between him and the child”
The court heard that James had given no explanation for the attack but previous text messages spoke of on-going issues about the child clinging to her mum and not taking to him. James also had concerns about Ms Parry’s parenting skills.
Graham Pickavance, prosecuting, said: “There was obviously some issue between him and the child and that morning there was a sustained attack on the child. There was shaking and bad bruising to both ears.
Judge Gary Woodhall said that the former support worker, who showed no emotion in court, had not demonstrated any remorse.
He said: “You continue to deny responsibility despite the fact that the evidence placed before the jury was clear that the offence must have happened when she was left in your care. It is likely you lost control… and assaulted her.”
The judge said: “It is clear that the toddler had not taken to you and would cry regularly in your company. I am satisfied you were finding that increasingly frustrating and you were unhappy with the way the mother was dealing with it.”
He said there had been earlier incidents including the girl suffering a significant bruise to the back of her head and a fractured skull, although it was not known if that had been accidental.
Domestic abuse help and support
Domestic violence or abuse can happen to anyone. Find out how and where to get help.
Advice from the NHS says that If you are at risk of domestic abuse or violence you can:
- talk to your doctor, health visitor or midwife
- women can call 0808 2000 247, the free 24-hour National Domestic Violence Helpline run in partnership between Women’s Aid and Refuge
- men can call the Men’s Advice Line free on 0808 801 0327 (Monday to Friday 9am to 5pm) or ManKind on 01823 334 244
- in an emergency, call 999
The Survivor’s Handbook from the charity Women’s Aid is free, and provides information for women on a wide range of issues, such as housing, money, helping your children, and your legal rights.
Men can also email email@example.com, which can refer men to local places that can help, such as health services and voluntary organisations.
For forced marriage and “honour” crimes, contact Karma Nirvana (0800 5999 247) or The Forced Marriage Unit (020 7008 0151).
Galop provides support to lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people experiencing domestic violence.
Anyone who needs confidential help with their own abusive behaviour can contact Respect on their free helpline on 0808 802 4040.
James was cleared by a jury of responsibility for that injury.
Temper or frustration
Sentencing James to seven years in prison, Judge Woodhall said: “Whatever suspicions there may be about previous violent actions to her, on the basis of the medical evidence and faithful to the jury’s not guilty verdict I am obliged to sentence you for a single incident of violence on September 1.
“I am satisfied that you had violently shaken that baby with sufficient force backwards and forwards to cause bleeding within the skull and within her eyes.”
He said that a doctor described it as “very serious and potentially life threatening.
Judge Woodhall said that “in all likelihood” he had acted in temper or out of frustration.
James, of Watersedge Apartments, Tower Promenade, New Brighton, Wirral, had been convicted of causing grievous bodily harm with intent on September 1, 2017 and acquitted of causing grievous bodily harm on or about August 27 that year.
The child’s mum, Kelly Parry, 31, of Islington, Liverpool, who was cleared of child cruelty, was present in the public gallery for today’s sentencing.
Graham Pickavance, prosecuting, told Liverpool Crown Court that James started a relationship with Parry in April 2017. She was living with her mother and the baby in Liverpool after separating from her husband, the child’s dad, who lived in Birkenhead.
On September 1 she left her daughter in the care of James, as she had a counselling appointment, and half an hour later he rang for an ambulance for the baby.
He later described putting her on the floor as she had been ‘sofa surfing’.
An ambulance took her to Alder Hey Hospital and her various injuries were discovered. A consultant neurologist said that in his opinion the bleeds the infant had suffered “were the result of shaking and the force needed would be obviously inappropriate to the person using it.”
Bernice Campbell, defending, said that James, who the judge had described as “very calm, controlled and measured” during proceedings, had been showing respect for the court.
He had immediately called for an ambulance when the toddler collapsed during the first time he had been left in sole charge of her and went to hospital with her by which time she had regained consciousness.